Captain Aaron took us offshore swiftly in his beautiful 36-38 foot contender CC and low and behold we got on some mahi (three at once) ! It was the show I have always dreamed of watching beautiful blue and green dolphin flying through the air! Aaron didn’t disappoint and landed all three on deck and we didn’t miss a beat! Ended up reef fishing later on in the trip for some different species and snagged some mutton snapper which was our target species. I’d go fish with this guy any day of the week and twice on Sunday! Left with 25lbs of fish cleaned and ready to grill, no more dinners out for a while!

My husband took me to Key West for my Birthday and the highlight of my stay was fishing with Captain Aaron. If you are in the Key West area & looking for an honest, reasonable and fun charter please look up Mutton to It. We had so much fun...a lot of trash talking was the highlight on who was catching the most and or biggest, also a discussion on cheese peanut butter crackers😂😂. Captain Aaron will definitely put you on fish and you will not leave empty handed. We will definitely be back!!!

This is the second time we have gone out with captain Aaron and had an awesome time. lots of action and lots of fun, a very good charter for anyone beginner or experienced anglers alike

What a trip! Could not ask for a better captain, guide or boat! Caught tons of fish and had a blast. Will be booking a fishing charter here for all of our yearly trips to the keys from now on. We have tried several fishing guides in Key West Florida but Mutton To It is by far the best!

Just went deep sea fishing with kids before they are off to college, had the best day ever. Captain Erin was not only extremely knowledgeable but made the experience what it was. Could not have had a better day. Caught lots of fish and we will definitely be back

Awesome trip with Capt. Aaron. Highly recommend booking a trip down in the keys. Contact him to coordinate a trip, he can customize the charter to cater to your specific fishing desire (e.g. offshore, deepdrop, 1/2 day, 3/4, or full day). Had a blast! Located in a beautiful Marina in front of very nice hotel resort, which makes it convenient. You can just walk right out of your room and onto the boat.